Virginia Court Finds Non-Compete Agreement Unenforceable

Posted on April 7, 2010 by H. Scott Johnson, Jr.

 

A recent decision from a Virginia Circuit Court serves as a worthwhile reminder to Virginia employers that not all non-compete agreements are enforceable. Although there was a non-compete agreement in place between a wholesale business and a former employee (who served as an account representative), the court in Specialty Marketing, Inc. v. Lawrence dismissed the breach of contract action because the agreement was geographically and functionally overbroad.

As we recently detailed in our series on business litigation claims, restrictive covenants (e.g., non-compete agreements) are disfavored in Virginia as they are restraints on trade. As such, it is the employer’s burden to prove that the restrictions are: 1) no greater than necessary to protect the employer’s legitimate business interest; and 2) not unduly harsh or oppressive in curtailing an employee’s ability to earn a livelihood. To determine whether an employer has met its burden, a Virginia court will look at the function, geographic scope, and duration of the non-compete agreement.

In Specialty Marketing, Inc. v. Lawrence, the non-compete agreement at issue provided that the employee could not “be employed by . . . any business competitive with Specialty in areas where Specialty has a market for its business.” The court concluded that this language was overbroad and unenforceable because it was unlimited in functional scope and far exceeded whatever limitation was necessary to protect the employer’s business interests. Additionally, the non-compete agreement was geographically overbroad as it was not limited to the area formerly serviced by the employee; nor was the agreement limited to a specific mile radius from the employee’s former territory.

As this case illustrates, simply having an agreement in place may not properly protect a Virginia business from competition by a former employee. To be upheld under Virginia law, the non-compete agreement must be narrowly tailored in terms of function, geographic scope, and time.


 

Tags: , , , , , , , ,